Is Next a golden cage?
Why is it so hard to leave React after years of use?
If you've been web developing for a few years, you've probably noticed a phenomenon: the "comfort zone" of React. Or perhaps, as some call it, the "golden cage." You've become incredibly productive. You know useState, useEffect, and the entire Next.js ecosystem inside out. You can build a full-stack site with routing, hybrid rendering, and APIs in an afternoon.
Yet, when you try to take a look at Svelte, Vue, or Astro, something doesn't "click." Everything seems unnecessarily complicated, or perhaps "too magical." Why? It's not a matter of intelligence. It's a matter of mental models. This is why it's so hard to leave React, even just to try something new.
How we got here: Next.js made everything easy
Remember the struggle to keep up with the myriad of JavaScript tools? Before Next.js, React was just a library. You had to choose and configure everything: router, state management, SSR. It was exhausting. Next.js came along and solved all that. It provided an "all-in-one" framework that made React development simple. File-based routing, great SEO, and zero configuration. Our loyalty is not (just) to React, the library. It's to Next.js, the integrated solution that eliminated decision fatigue. We became dependent not on the library, but on the complete solution.
It's Not the syntax, it's the brain
The real barrier is cognitive. Years of React have trained your brain to "think" about web development in a very specific way. The React mindset: "State changes. I re-run the entire component. The Virtual DOM will figure out what to update." This has forced you to become an expert in optimizing re-renders. You spend time using useMemo and useCallback to prevent the app from slowing down. When you see Svelte, there's no V-DOM. It's a compiler. It writes JavaScript code that updates the DOM surgically. Your skill in optimizing re-renders is suddenly useless. "State is immutable. To change it, I call setState(), which will trigger a new render with the new state." You can't update a state and read it immediately after. When you see Vue, reactivity is based on Proxy. You can simply write state.value++ and the DOM updates. It feels like "magic" or "dangerous" to your React-trained brain, which expects an explicit unidirectional data flow.
The clash of paradigms
The difficulty in transitioning from React to another framework is akin to switching from a Romance language to a tonal language. The foundational concepts are different.
| Problem | React | Svelte |
|---|---|---|
| Creating state | const [val, setVal] = useState(0) | let val = 0 |
| Creating derived state | const double = useMemo(...) | $: double = val * 2 |
| Optimizing | React.memo(), useCallback() | The compiler does it for you |
Is it worth leaving the cage?
It depends. React and Next.js are fantastic tools, but they are just some of the tools.
- Astro is incredible for high-performance content sites.
- Svelte offers a simpler development experience and lighter bundles.
- Vue and Nuxt are praised for their intuitive "developer experience."
Being stuck in the "comfort zone" of React is convenient, but it prevents you from using the best tool for the job.
The next time you try a new framework, don't try to "find the equivalent of useEffect." Try to understand its mental model from scratch. It might take a while, but it will be worth it.
Tags: